Essay

Good Enough to Exist

In a bookstore with my daughter, I felt something loosen: writing doesn't have to be good enough to exist, it just has to exist. Anne Lamott explains why.

The shelf

My daughter had wandered three aisles ahead of me, pulling books halfway off the shelf and sliding them back, the way she does when she’s not looking for anything in particular. I was running a finger along a row of spines, not really looking either, just taking it in. Literary fiction next to a self-published memoir with a homemade cover next to a paperback mystery so worn the pages had gone soft at the corners.

Somewhere in the middle of that shelf, something in me loosened.

The parameter I didn’t know I’d set

I spent most of my life believing there was a right way to write. Not a preference. A standard.

It came from school, from years of being handed a rubric before I was handed a blank page: this is the structure, this is the tone, this is what counts as good. I didn’t question it because I never had to. Somebody else always decided what counted.

So without ever deciding to, I built a version of writing that was mostly about clearing a bar someone else had set. If a sentence didn’t sound like it belonged in the kind of writing I’d been trained to produce, I cut it before it finished forming. I wasn’t writing. I was auditioning.

Standing in that bookstore, watching my daughter get distracted by a cover, I realized how much of that bar was just furniture I’d never moved. Every book on that shelf had gotten there by a different route, in a different voice, following different rules, or none.

The way I write isn’t right or wrong. It’s just the way I write. That’s not a lower bar. It’s a different question entirely.

What Lamott knew about the first version

Anne Lamott spent years writing restaurant reviews for a magazine, and by her own account she never once sat down and produced a clean draft. She’d go to dinner, take notes, and then stall for most of a day: writing a sentence, crossing it out, trying again, feeling something like dread settle into her chest before she’d finally let herself write the bad version. Long, self-indulgent, no real ending. Then the next day she’d go back through it with a pen and cut it into something worth reading.

Her line for it has stuck with people for thirty years because it isn’t really about writing: “almost all good writing begins with terrible first efforts.” Not most. Almost all. Including hers, including the writers she admired most.

What she’s describing isn’t a trick for getting unstuck. It’s a structural fact about how anything gets made. The bad version isn’t a failure to avoid. It’s the only door into the good one.

The part that doesn’t resolve

Permission to write badly is not the same as knowing the writing is any good.

I can stand in a bookstore and feel the full weight of “my way of writing is valid” and still sit down at my desk the next morning and not know if what I make is worth anyone’s time. Those are two different problems, and I used to think solving the first one would quietly solve the second. It doesn’t. A thoughtful skeptic would point out, correctly, that plenty of books on that same shelf probably shouldn’t have been published. Feeling like your voice is allowed to exist doesn’t make it good.

I don’t think the answer is to pretend that tension away. I think the honest version is closer to this: you can’t find out whether something is good without first letting it exist in a bad form. Mattering and being good aren’t the same question, but the only way to reach the second one is to walk through the first.

What it actually looks like now

Most mornings I still catch the old rubric running in the background. I’ll write a paragraph and hear some version of a professor’s red pen before I’ve even finished the sentence. Not good enough. Too casual. That’s not how this is supposed to sound.

What’s different isn’t that the voice went away. It’s that I’ve started writing anyway, mid-sentence, with it still talking. I let the bad paragraph stay on the page instead of deleting it before it’s finished being wrong.

I come back to it the next day the way Lamott came back to her reviews: with a pen, not a verdict. Some days that’s the whole win. Not confidence that it’s good. Just enough trust in the process to let a bad draft sit there long enough to become something else.

I’m not going to tell you I’ve stopped being self-critical, because I haven’t. I still don’t know, most days, whether what I write is any good. I’ve just stopped requiring an answer to that question before I’m allowed to start.

What you might be withholding

You might be sitting on something right now that you’ve decided isn’t ready. A business idea you haven’t said out loud. A conversation you keep rehearsing instead of having. A version of yourself you’re waiting to feel more sure of before you let anyone see it.

Somewhere, your version of that thing is going to overlap with somebody else’s life in a way you can’t predict from the outside, the way a stranger’s paperback on a bookstore shelf might land in exactly the hands that needed it. You don’t get to know that in advance. You only find out by letting the bad first version exist long enough to become something else.

What are you withholding until it’s good enough to exist? And what would it cost you to let the bad draft of it stand for a while, unfinished, instead of deleting it before anyone, including you, gets to see what it might become?

Wade Arave
Written by
Wade Arave

Higher education leader, writer, and builder. More essays →

A letter every other Sunday. Drafts, not noise.